Non DubitoEssays in the Self-as-an-End Tradition
← Reading All Quiet on the Western Front← 《西线无战事》解读
Essay III of III · All Quiet on the Western Front《西线无战事》解读 · III / III

That Line in the Communiqué

战报上那一句

Sep 5, 2026Han Qin (秦汉)Complete English edition中文原作 · 简 / 繁

Edition note: A complete English rendering of the Chinese essay, preserving its scenes and argument. Full-book spoilers.

He opens the door, sees his sister, and begins to cry before he can speak. He had not expected it. Two years at the front without crying, and now the tears come at his own front door.

His mother is ill upstairs. She sits up and asks if it is very hard out there. Not so bad, Mother, he says. He throws his uniform into a corner and puts on his prewar clothes. They are too small and feel strange. His mother likes seeing him in them. His father wants him back in uniform to meet some friends. He does not go.

A major in the street berates him for saluting incorrectly. A tram sounds like an incoming shell. At night his father asks about the front, including hand-to-hand fighting. Paul gets up and leaves. Speaking is not merely unwelcome: it is dangerous. Once those things become words, he may not be able to hold them down.

Later he sits alone in his room. His books are still on the shelves, bought one at a time with his own money. He takes them down and opens them, waiting for the old quiet pleasure. Nothing returns. He puts them back. The words in his mind are: never again.

He has returned to the place that should belong to him. Nothing there has changed. What has changed is that it no longer has room for him. Afterwards he says he should never have come home.


Some of his father's acquaintances sit in a beer hall. One is an old headmaster.

Paul offers an opinion. The headmaster brushes it aside: Paul knows details, but this is about the whole; a man who sees only his own stretch of front cannot judge the entire line. Then he explains the strategy. Break through in Flanders, roll the enemy up from top to bottom, and march on Paris. He blows his nose and wipes his moustache.

Formally, this is a serious objection, perhaps the hardest in the book. A soldier in one trench really cannot see the whole front as someone with a map can. The headmaster is not necessarily lying or pretending. He believes the argument he is making.

What is missing lies elsewhere. The man with the whole picture does not have to pay for being wrong with his own body. His finger follows a line on the map; other bodies walk it. If they cannot get through, the bill does not bear his name. Tomorrow he will sit at the same table with the same beer.

We heard this argument in the first essay, in a school gymnastics lesson. It now has a more respectable setting, but the shape is the same. As Paul leaves, the headmaster puts cigars in his pocket, pats him kindly and hopes for good news soon.


Paul visits his old classmate Mittelstaedt. Kantorek has been called up and is now a recruit under him.

The former teacher stands on the parade ground in an ill-fitting old uniform. Mittelstaedt drills him like any other recruit. At the horizontal bar he lifts him by the waistband until his chin reaches it, offering advice from beside him, exactly as Kantorek used to do at school. He repeats the teacher's old sayings back to him, word for word.

The scene is satisfying. Remarque does not disguise its pleasure. Paul watches and remembers being afraid of this man.

Between these two, the account balances, and there it ends. Mittelstaedt recovers his own share in full. Behm is not in that account. There is no way to put him there.


Near the end of his leave, Paul visits Kemmerich's mother.

Her first question is why Paul is alive when her son is dead.

She wants to know how he died. Paul says a shot in the chest killed him instantly; he did not suffer. She does not believe him. He repeats it. She demands an oath, and he swears by everything sacred that if it is untrue, he may never come back. Later he says he would have sworn any oath she wanted. He can make it precisely because nothing remains for him to swear by.

She believes him. As he leaves she gives him her son's photograph: a recruit in uniform beside a round table with birch-branch legs, a glass of beer on it, a painted wood behind. It is the studio backdrop before which so many conscripted boys had stood.

The wood is painted. The beer is a prop. The uniform is real.

On his last night his mother enters his room. She thinks he is asleep, so he pretends to be. Neither speaks; speech would hurt too much. She sits for a long time, herself convulsed with pain. Unable to bear it, he pretends to wake and sends her back to bed. Before he leaves she gives him an undergarment she cannot really afford.

He calls the leave an interruption that only makes what follows harder to endure. More briefly: he should never have come back.


What follows happens quickly.

Detering is a farmer. For two years he has carried his yard and the crops his wife must bring in alone inside him. One day he sees a cherry tree in blossom, remembers the trees at home and brings a branch back to his quarters. A few nights later he leaves, heading home. Military police catch him in Germany and send him before a court martial. The novel's last word on him is that they never hear of him again.

A flare strikes Müller in the stomach at close range. He survives half an hour, conscious throughout and in terrible pain. He leaves Paul his boots, the pair that once belonged to Kemmerich. Paul wears them; they fit well. He has promised them to Tjaden after him.

Kat is shot in the lower leg and will not stop bleeding. Paul carries him a long way towards the dressing station, talking to him and thinking about finding him food. An orderly takes one look and says he is dead. On the way a tiny fragment struck Kat's head. Paul noticed nothing as he carried him.


Of the twenty classmates, Paul is the last. He falls in October 1918, on a day so quiet along the front that the military communiqué has only the line that gives the novel its title.

The report does not lie. It measures movement on the front, and the front has not moved. It is not missing a column: it is a document about a front, never pretending to be a document about individual people. Asking it to record this one death is like asking a ruler to admit it cannot measure temperature.

The problem is that this sentence is what remains of the day. Not that the record lies, but that without another record, its way of measuring becomes the whole event. The novel is the other account someone returns to write ten years later.

Paul falls forward as if asleep. When he is turned over, it seems he cannot have suffered long. His expression is calm, almost as though he were content that it had ended this way.

Reading note: This essay discusses Remarque's novel rather than the films. The Chinese essay follows Zhu Wen's translation (2017 revised edition); translations by Jiang Yi and Yan Huiling are also available.

版本说明:中文原作;简体与繁体同页切换。全文剧透。

他推开门,看见姐姐,一句话没说出来就哭了。他自己也没料到会这样——他在前线待了两年没有哭过,进了自己家门,眼泪就下来了。

母亲在楼上病着,坐起来问他,外面是不是很苦。他说还好,母亲,还过得去。他把军装扔进墙角,从柜子里翻出战前的便服穿上,衣服小了,穿在身上别扭。母亲喜欢他这样,父亲希望他把军装穿回去,好带他去见几个朋友,他没有去。

街上有个少校因为他敬礼不合规矩把他骂了一顿。电车开过来的声音像一发炮弹正朝他飞过来。父亲晚上问了很多前线的事,问到有没有过肉搏,他起身走了出去——他不是不愿意说,是说出来太危险,一旦把那些东西变成话,他就压不住它们了。

后来他一个人坐在自己房间里。书还在架上,一本一本地摆着,是他自己一本一本买回来的。他把它们取下来,翻开,等着从前那种安静的欢喜回来。什么也没有回来。他把书放回架上,心里出现的是一个词:再也不会了。

他回到了那个理应属于他的地方。那个地方一样也没有变,变的是他在里面已经没有位置。他后来给这次探亲下了一句话:我本来就不该回来。

*

啤酒馆里坐着父亲的几个熟人,其中一位是老校长。

保罗说了一句自己的看法。校长把它挡了回去,语气是居高临下的:细节你懂,可这是全局的事,全局你判断不了;你只看得见自己那一小段战线,看不到整个面。然后他讲了应该怎么打——先在佛兰德斯把对面的战线突破,然后从上往下卷,卷得干干净净,从头卷到尾,然后打到巴黎。他擤了擤鼻子,擦了擦胡子。

校长这个反驳在形式上是成立的,它甚至是全书最难拆的一句话。保罗确实只看得见自己那一小段战线,一个趴在战壕里的人对整条战线的判断,确实不如一个能摊开地图的人。校长没有说谎,也没有装糊涂,他讲的是他真的相信的一套推演。

缺的东西在别处。有全局的那个人,判断错了不需要用自己的身体去付。他手指划过地图上那条线,走那条线的是别人的身体;走不通的时候,这笔账不记在他名下,第二天他还坐在同一张桌子边,还是那杯啤酒。

这句话在第一篇里出现过一次,在一间中学的体操课上。它在这里换了个位置,换了一个更体面的场合,形状一模一样。临走时校长往保罗口袋里塞了几支雪茄,很和气地拍了拍他,说盼着早点听到你们的好消息。

*

保罗去看了老同学米特尔施泰特。康托列克被征召了,正在他手下当新兵。

他穿着一身完全不合身的旧军装站在操场上。米特尔施泰特把他当新兵操,做单杠的时候抓住他的裤腰把他往上提一提,让他下巴刚好够到杠子,然后在旁边替他出主意——那正是康托列克当年在学校里对他做过的事。他还把康托列克在课堂上说过的话,一句一句原样还了回去。

这一段读起来是痛快的,它确实痛快,而且雷马克写的时候也没有克制。保罗站在旁边看,想起自己当年怕过这个人。

而这笔账在他们两个人之间收支平衡了,然后就结束了。米特尔施泰特讨回了自己那一份,一分不少。贝姆不在这笔账里,也没有办法被列进去。

*

假期快完的时候,保罗去看克默里希的母亲。

她问的第一句是:那你为什么活着,他死了。

她要知道儿子是怎么死的。保罗说是胸口中弹,当场就死了,没有受罪。她不信。他把这个说法又说了一遍,她还是不信,要他起誓。他起了誓,用他所有神圣的东西起誓:要是这不是真的,就让他永远回不来。他后来写,这种誓他愿意发任何一种。他发得出这个誓,恰恰是因为他已经没有可以用来发誓的东西了。

她信了。临走她给了他一张儿子的照片:新兵制服,靠着一张桦树枝当腿的圆桌,桌上摆着一杯啤酒,身后的幕布上画着一片树林。这是照相馆里的布景,那年头每个应征的男孩都在这样一块幕布前面照过一张。

那片树林是画上去的,那杯啤酒是道具,而那身制服是真的。

在家的最后一夜,母亲半夜进了他的房间。她以为他睡着了,他也就装着睡。两个人都不说话,因为说话太难受。她坐了很久,自己疼得直抽搐。他实在受不了,装作刚醒,让她回去睡。走的时候她给了他一件内衣,那是她其实买不起的。

他后来给探亲假下了一句话:这是一次停顿,而停顿只会让后面的一切更难熬。他还写了一句更短的:我本来不该回来。

*

后面的事发生得很快。

德特林是个农民,两年里心里装的一直是他那个院子和他妻子一个人在收的庄稼。一天他看见路边一棵樱桃树开了花,想起自家院子里那几棵,折了一枝带回住处。过了几夜他一个人走了,方向是家。宪兵在德国境内抓住了他,送上军事法庭。这本书对他的最后一句话是:此后再没有听到过他的消息。

米勒在极近的距离上被一发照明弹打进肚子,撑了半个小时,神志从头到尾都是清醒的,疼得厉害。临死他把靴子留给了保罗——那双靴子原是克默里希的。保罗写:我穿着,很合脚;我之后就归恰登了,我答应过他。

卡特小腿中弹,血止不住。保罗把他背在背上往包扎所走,走了很远,一路上还在跟他说话,还想着接下来该怎么给他弄点吃的。到了地方,卫生员看了一眼就说这个人已经死了。路上有一小块弹片打中了卡特的头,很小的一块,保罗背着他走的时候什么也没有察觉。

*

班上二十个人,到这时候只剩他一个。一九一八年十月,他倒下了。那一天整条战线安静得没有什么可写,军方的战报只有一句话,就是这本书的书名。

那份战报没有说谎,一个字也没有。它量的是战线的移动,而那一天战线确实没有动过。它不是缺了一栏,它是一份关于战线的文件,从来没有假装自己是一份关于人的文件。要它把那天死的一个人算进去,等于要一把尺子承认自己量不出温度。

问题是那一天世界上留下来的只有这一句。不是这份记录撒了谎,是除了它以外再没有别的记录,而一件事如果只剩一种量法,那种量法就成了它的全部。这本书是十年之后有人回过头去补上的另一份。

他向前扑倒,趴在地上,像是睡着了。翻过来看,他没有受多久的罪。他脸上的神情很平静,几乎像是满意于事情就这样结束了。

本文依据朱雯译本(上海人民出版社/世纪文景 2017 修订版),人名从该本。另有姜乙译本(上海文艺 2021)、顏徽玲译本(上海译文 2022)通行。本文只处理小说,不涉及一九三〇年与二〇二二年两个电影版。

← Previous: The Man in the Shell Hole← 上一篇:弹坑里那个人Literature library →文学目录 →