Edition note: Independently rewritten for English-language readers from the Chinese essay’s argument and close reading. Full-book spoilers.
As a teenage laborer at La Mora, Anguilla watches the landowner’s three daughters from across a class boundary. Irene is beautiful, gentle, and prepared to marry well. Silvia is restless and refuses the approved path. Santa, the youngest, is still a child when Anguilla leaves.
La Mora is the brightest interval of his youth: food, work, conversation, and first knowledge of a world beyond the valley. The sisters seem to possess everything he lacks—father, surname, home, dowry, and a recognized place.
When he returns, the stories of their deaths come out. Irene married Arturo, whom she had not wanted and whom her father had initially opposed. After her father fell ill, Arturo got his way, squandered the dowry, and beat her. She is dead when Anguilla returns. Silvia became pregnant, went secretly to a midwife, and bled to death after returning home.
The two daughters take different roads. Irene had resisted Arturo, but entered the marriage all the same. Elvira first approved of him, then wanted to keep the dowry at home; Arturo turned the household’s changed fortunes to his advantage. Silvia took matters into her own hands, but could do so only in secret. Neither daughter’s wishes were enough to determine what happened to her.
La Mora’s household collapses. Arturo sells property; the people scatter. When Anguilla returns, even the pine by the gate has been cut down. The poorest house at Gaminella still shelters another family. What seemed the more durable life at La Mora has gone.
Santa’s story arrives differently. When Anguilla asks, Nuto gives him some pieces but holds back the end. Santa grew beautiful, went to Canelli, and spent time among the Black Brigades. Then she disappeared.
The silence belongs to the whole valley, not only to Santa. Fascists, Germans, and partisans passed through. Local people chose sides, crossed between sides, informed, fought, and killed one another. Once the fighting was over, not everyone wanted to tell those stories.
Irene was hurt inside a marriage she had not wanted. Silvia tried to find her own way and died after a clandestine abortion. Santa entered a conflict larger than the village and was killed there. Pavese does not call this fate. In each life he shows particular people and pressures: a marriage negotiated through reputation and property, a pregnancy that could not be spoken of, a wartime judgment.
Anguilla once imagined the sisters fortunate because their identities were anchored in family and land. He, the hired boy who could not name his origins, survived after leaving; all three recognized daughters died. The reversal proves no comforting law. Poverty does not protect, travel does not guarantee survival, and rootedness is not security.
It changes only what Anguilla is asking from home. He came looking for a stable past capable of witnessing him. The people who seemed most securely placed have disappeared, and the person who remembers them cannot yet bring himself to speak. A village preserves a life only through particular people, and particular people may carry reasons for silence.
Cesare Pavese’s La luna e i falò (The Moon and the Bonfires), published in 1950. Full-book spoilers.
版本说明:中文原作;简体与繁体同页切换。全文剧透。
莫拉是这个山谷里最像样的一个农庄。
鳗鱼十几岁的时候在那里做长工。主人是马泰奥先生,有地,有牲口,有仆人;家里有三个女儿:伊雷内,西尔维娅,还有最小的桑塔。书里写鳗鱼在那几年的日子,是全书最亮的一段——他有饭吃,有活干,有人跟他说话;他在那里学会了看世界,认识了努托,第一次听人说起外面的事情。而他每天看着那三个女孩。
伊雷内是大的,长得好看,弹钢琴,性子软,规矩;她是那种被家里当成"要嫁得好"的那一个,书里写她被带去镇上,被介绍给合适的人家,被人打量。西尔维娅是二的,性子野,不听话;她骑马,她跟人来往,她不肯照规矩来,书里写她那些年到处跑,跟不同的人在一起,村里有闲话。桑塔是最小的,那时候还是个孩子,书里写她小时候的样子:机灵,好看,谁见了都喜欢。
而鳗鱼那时候是长工,他站在院子里,看着这一家人吃饭、说话、来客人——他跟她们之间隔着一整个阶层,他连跟她们说话的资格都很有限。书里写他那时候对她们的感情写得很实:那是一个十几岁的长工对主人家小姐的那种东西,是仰望,是好奇,是一点说不出口的东西;他知道那跟他没有关系。
而他回来之后,一个一个打听这三个人,答案是努托给的。
伊雷内嫁给了阿图罗。阿图罗早就追求过她,她不愿意,马泰奥先生起初也反对。后来老人病得不能管事,阿图罗终于占了上风。他卖掉产业,耗光了嫁妆,还打她。鳗鱼回来时,伊雷内也已不在。西尔维娅怀了孕,瞒着家里去找一个接生婆打胎,回来后流血不止,死的时候低声叫着爸爸。
而这两条线加起来,是这本书对那个家最狠的一次判断。两个女儿走的是不同的路。伊雷内原先不愿意嫁给阿图罗,最终还是被卷进那门让她失去财产、挨了打的亲事;西尔维娅自己去找走掉的人,自己拿主意,最后也只好瞒着所有人做那件事。走的是两条路,而两个人自己的意思都不足以决定她们的处境。
而这一点要说清楚:不能把这门婚事归成父亲一个人挑了一个人。埃尔维拉起先觉得阿图罗合适,后来又想把嫁妆留在家里;阿图罗趁老人生病、西尔维娅的事坏了家里名声,变成了一个看似肯施惠的人。各人算的是名声、嫁妆、谁来管这个家;伊雷内自己愿不愿意,在这些账里没有多少分量。
而莫拉这个家最后也垮了。马泰奥先生病倒后,产业被分卖,人一个一个散了。鳗鱼回来的时候,当年的生活早已没有了,连门口那棵松树,也被尼科莱托叫人砍掉了。
这一点值得看一眼,因为它跟第二篇讲的东西是连着的。莫拉当年是这个山谷里最稳的一家:有地,有房,有三个女儿,有一份看得见的将来。卡米内拉那栋破房子还住着人,现在住的是钦托一家;而莫拉当年那一家人,早先中意的将来一件也没剩下。三个女儿,一个在坏婚事里挨了打,后来不在了;一个死于打胎;一个是第四篇的事。
而三个人里最小的那一个,是这本书最后要交代的。
桑塔那时候是个孩子。鳗鱼记得她六岁时的样子,努托见过她二十岁的样子。鳗鱼回来一路打听,问到她的时候,努托不太说。
这个"不太说"是这本书后半部分的节奏:鳗鱼问,努托岔开;鳗鱼再问,努托说"以后再说";这样反复了好几次,一直到最后。而这中间,鳗鱼从别人嘴里听到了一些零碎的——说她后来长得极好看,说她去了加内利,说战争的时候她跟一些人来往,说她在那边有名。而没有一个人说她后来怎么样了。
要理解这个沉默,得先说清楚那些年这个山谷里发生了什么。书里写得不多,而写到的部分很硬:战争打到这一带,德国人来过,法西斯的部队来过,山上有游击队。那几年这个山谷里的人分了边,而分边这件事是要命的:有人上了山,有人替另一边做事,有人两边都沾。有人告密,有人死在熟人手里。战后也不是人人都愿意说起这些事。
一个村子,几百口人,互相认识了几代;而在那几年里,这些人开始按边站,然后开始互相处理。这就是那个沉默的内容:努托不肯说的,不是桑塔一个人的事,是那几年这个山谷里所有人做过的事。
现在把这三个人排一遍,因为这是这本书对那套东西的完整说明:伊雷内进了那门亲事,在里面挨了打;西尔维娅走了另一条路,死于一次瞒着人的打胎;桑塔进了一个更大的局,也死了。三条不同的路,而这本书没有替任何一个人补出一条出路。
而这本书没有把这写成命运。它把每一条的经过一件件交代出来:伊雷内那门婚事里有嫁妆、名声,也有阿图罗做过的事;西尔维娅死于打胎,这件事之所以不能声张,跟那个年代一个未婚女子怀孕意味着什么分不开;桑塔则死在那几年的暴力里。每一条上面都有具体的人,具体的规矩,具体的做法,没有一条是老天爷安排的。
而这一篇最后要说的,是鳗鱼在这一整件事里的位置。他在莫拉做长工的那几年,是他这一生里最好的几年——第一篇讲过,他在那里有饭吃,有活干,第一次听人说起外面;而他站在那个位置上,看着那三个女孩,他当时以为她们是幸运的那一批。她们有父亲,有姓,有家,有出生记录,有嫁妆;她们是被养大的,不是被领养的;她们在那个村子里有位置。而他什么也没有——他是个弃儿,是个长工,是别人每月一笔补贴养大的那一个。
二十年之后他回来,她们三个都不在了,而他还在。书里没有让他说出这一层,而它就在那儿:那个什么也没有的人活下来了,那三个什么都有的人一个也没有留住。而这件事说明不了任何道理——它不说明穷人比富人命长,也不说明走出去比留下来强,它只是这个山谷里发生过的事。
而鳗鱼回来之后,认识了一个孩子。那孩子住在卡米内拉,就是他小时候住过的那栋破房子;孩子叫钦托,一条腿是瘸的,家里穷得不成样子,父亲脾气极坏。鳗鱼给他讲外面的事,给他买东西,跟他说话。
而下一篇是这本书的最后一段。那里有两场火:一场是钦托家的,一场是很多年前的。而努托最后说出了桑塔的下场。
本篇所据为切萨雷·帕韦泽的长篇小说 La luna e i falò(一九五〇年出版)。文中书名、人名、地名按本文所用译名书写。