Edition note: Independently rewritten for English-language readers from the Chinese essay’s argument and close reading. Full-book spoilers.
The narrator of The Moon and the Bonfires does not give us his name. People call him Anguilla—Eel—a nickname Emilia gave him in his youth. The man can write his name now, he tells us; the reader never sees it.
He was abandoned. A poor household at Gaminella took him in, and received a monthly payment for raising him. The money came from the hospital in Alessandria; the household collected five lire at the town hall. By the time he was old enough to work, the money had stopped. What counted now was his labor. He grew up beside two girls, worked, and went hungry with them. Each step in the arrangement is defensible. The hospital found the child a home; a household that needed cash gave him somewhere to grow up.
What the arrangement does not give him is a way to answer who he is. He does not know his parents or his birthplace. There may still be a file at the town hall. A file is not the same thing as an origin, and a nickname is useful only while somebody knows who it means.
Anguilla leaves the valley for about twenty years, goes to Genoa and to America, and makes money. Those years appear in fragments. The book’s movement begins when he returns to the Piedmont valley and walks from house to farm, tree to road, asking what became of everyone.
He appears to be revisiting home, but he is also searching for evidence. For someone who does not know where he began, slopes and other people’s memories can testify that his early years happened and that he was in them.
Most of the witnesses have vanished. Another family occupies the Gaminella house; the hazels are gone. La Mora is no longer the household Anguilla knew. People have died, scattered, or fallen silent after fascism, occupation, partisan war, and postwar reprisals. Anguilla can buy property; locals assume that is why a returnee from America has come. Ownership would not answer him. He needs the past fact that he lived here, and no one can sell that fact back.
One person remains: Nuto, a carpenter who played the clarinet in a band and kept his life rooted in the valley. He knows who married, who died, which farm changed hands, and what people did during the war. No list of dates could tell these stories. Nuto himself is a living archive.
The novel places the traveler and the stayer side by side. Anguilla has money, America, and the freedom to return. Nuto has continuity. Each possesses what the other lacks, but neither can simply transfer it. Anguilla’s journey home becomes a conversation with someone who can still attest to the life behind his nickname.
Cesare Pavese’s La luna e i falò (The Moon and the Bonfires), published in 1950. Full-book spoilers.
版本说明:中文原作;简体与繁体同页切换。全文剧透。
这本书的叙述者没有把他的姓名告诉读者。
书里的人管他叫“鳗鱼”。那是他年轻时埃米莉娅给他起的绰号。他后来已经能写自己的名字,读者却从头到尾没有看见那个名字。
他是一个弃儿。亚历山德里亚的医院把他交给一户住在卡米内拉的穷人家。那里有一栋两间屋带一间牲口棚的小房子,有一只山羊,还有一片长着榛树的坡地。领他的是维尔吉利娅和他后来叫作“教父”的那个人;家里还有两个女孩,他把她们当姐姐。
而这家人领他,是因为每个月有一笔钱。按他的回忆,亚历山德里亚的医院付这笔钱,家里去市镇公所领五里拉。对一户穷得只有一只羊的人家来说,钱不算多,却是一笔实实在在的进项。书里写得毫不避讳:这一家人拿了那笔钱,也指望等他大些,全家能一起干活。等他长大一点,补贴已经停了。后来“教父”带着两个女孩搬去了科萨诺,他留在这一带,去了别处做长工。
停下来看这个安排,因为它是这本书全部的地基。一个孩子在这套安排里,先是一笔钱,然后是一双手。这两样之间没有过渡,也没有别的栏目。医院把孩子交给人家养,农户收钱是因为家里缺现钱;等他大到能下地,要紧的便不再是那笔钱,是那双手。
而每一步都说得过去。医院给孩子找了地方,补贴也让他有饭吃、有地方住。书里写这家人对他不算坏,他跟两个女孩一起长大,一起干活,一起挨饿。而在这一整套安排里,始终没有弄清一个问题:这个孩子是谁。他不知道自己生在哪里,也不知道父母是谁。他去过亚历山德里亚的医院,镇公所的人还说公所里也许还存着他的材料。但有一份材料,与知道自己从哪里来,是两件事。
而"鳗鱼"这个绰号,是这本书里最好的一处细节。
它不是一个家族的名字,是埃米莉娅给他的一个称呼;绰号像别人给你安上的一个把手,方便他们叫你。一个有家族名字的人,那个名字可以跟一个家族、一个生日、一份记录连起来,哪怕那个人死了,名字还在某个本子上。而这个绰号连着的是叫过他的人,只在他们还认得它的时候管用。
所以这个人的处境是:在这个山谷里,能说明他曾经在这里的凭据,很大一部分是一群人嘴上的一个称呼。
而这本书开始的时候,他已经不是那个孩子了。他离开山谷约二十年,去过热那亚,也去了美国,在加利福尼亚做过活,后来挣到了钱。书里没有把那二十年一一交代,只写了几个片段。一个人一生中被看作最“成功”的那些年,并不是小说真正要追查的东西。
他有钱了,他可以去任何地方,而他回到了这个山谷。
回来做什么?书里的第一章就在处理这个问题,而它给的答案是绕的:他说他回来不是为了做生意,不是为了买地,不是为了给谁看,他说他就是想回来看看。而看着看着,读者会发现他在干一件很具体的事。
他在找证据。他到处走——他去卡米内拉那栋破房子,站在外面看;他去莫拉那个他做过长工的农庄,看那些屋子还在不在;他沿着河走,认那些树,那些坡,那些路口。他问人:他问那户人家后来怎么样了,问那个女孩嫁去了哪里,问某某人还在不在,问那年发生的事。
而他要核对的,是那些年确实发生过,而且他在里面。这一点在书里没有被直说,却是全书的动力:一个不知道自己从哪里来、在村里只留下一个绰号的人,要找自己早年存在过的证据,能靠的是这些坡、这些树,和还记得他的那些人。如果这些东西不在了,还有什么能替他的前二十年作证?
而他回来发现的是:那些东西大部分不在了。卡米内拉那栋房子还在,住在里面的是别人,当年的榛树已经不见。莫拉也不再是他记得的那户人家。他认识的人,死的死,散的散,他打听到的往往只是些零碎的消息。
而中间还隔着一场战争。他离开的那些年,这个山谷打过仗:德国人来过,法西斯来过,游击队在山上打过;有人被枪毙,有人被吊死,有人失踪。书里写他一路问过去,问到某些事的时候,人们不说了。那些沉默是这本书后半部分的内容。
而这一篇最要紧的一件事,是他手上那笔钱。他有钱,而那笔钱在这件事上一点用也没有:他可以买下卡米内拉那栋房子,可以买下莫拉,可以在这个山谷里买很多地——书里有人这么建议过,也有人以为他就是回来干这个的。而那不解决任何问题,因为他要的不是那些东西的所有权,他要的是那些年他在这里的时候,他在这里。而这一样,钱买不到,也没有任何人能卖给他——一个人要说清楚"我是谁",需要有人能替他作证,而那些能作证的人一个一个不在了。
不过有一个人还在。
他叫努托,是鳗鱼小时候的朋友,比他大几岁,是个木匠,会吹单簧管,年轻的时候跟着乐队跑过许多地方。在这个山谷里,他是个见过世面的人。而努托没有远走,他在这一带以木工为业,成了家,也一直知道这里发生了什么:谁家出了什么事,哪一年谁死了,战争的时候谁做了什么。
而这本书的形状,就是这两个人的对照:一个离开山谷约二十年才回来的人,和一个始终跟这片地方连着的人。
下一篇讲他们两个的关系,也讲这本书里最有名的一句话。那句话是关于"一个人为什么需要一个村子"的,而说这句话的人,正是那个没有村子的人。
本篇所据为切萨雷·帕韦泽的长篇小说 La luna e i falò(一九五〇年出版)。文中书名、人名、地名按本文所用译名书写,包括 Anguilla(鳗鱼)、Nuto(努托)、Cinto(钦托)、Valino(瓦利诺)、Sor Matteo(马泰奥先生)、Irene(伊雷内)、Silvia(西尔维娅)、Santa(桑塔)、Gaminella(卡米内拉)、La Mora(莫拉)、Canelli(加内利)。